
My desk at the Decatur House/WHHS (No, I did not frame those Jackie Kennedy pictures, they were there when I arrived. . . although that does seem like something I would do.
)
I haven’t really said much about my research and exactly what I’m working on at the Decatur House this summer. There’s a pretty good reason for that: To be totally honest, I wasn’t entirely sure.
Yes, I have a job description (“Research this house and write something”), a formal research proposal (“Let me try and make this sound legit as it could change based on what I find . . .”), and a series of deadlines (Which, thank goodness I looked at the other day because I have a draft due at the end of July. Yikes!). But the thing about research is that it’s like a treasure hunt . . . on a good day you find great things, but on most days you sit there in a quasi-existential crisis thinking “WHAT DOES IT ALL MEAN?”
For the past month I have been in the throws of all of these possible scenarios. And here is what I’ve got so far jumbling around in my head. . . [This is also a good opportunity for me to summarize for my own sake . . .]
A SUMMARY OF THE MUSH THAT SOMEHOW MUST BECOME AN ARGUMENT . . .
I’m predominately interested in how Stephen Decatur established an elite residential neighborhood in the area around Lafayette Square through proximity, status, land speculation, and architectural design.
Stephen Decatur and his wife Susan Wheeler Decatur (daughter of the Mayor of Norfolk, VA, and supposedly “quite the catch”) moved to Washington around 1815 (excuse the approximate dates, but my bed is comfy I don’t feel like looking this up right now); Stephen having assumed a post as a chief navy officer for the US military. Taking advantage of the glory, celebrity, and financial clout from his many naval feats during the War of 1812, Stephen invested his money in the City of Washington’s highest stakes game: land speculation.
From 1817-1819, he acquired approximately twenty lots on eleven squares in the City of Washington.* [The city is divided up into squares, and the squares are divided into lots.] *Again, numbers are approximate because it would involve counting and it’s almost my bedtime. “Why on earth does he want to do that?” you ask. Well my friends, I [sort of] have an answer: LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. He doesn’t invest in just any land. Stephen specifically purchased lots in squares adjacent to the President’s House (the White House) on President’s Park (now Lafayette Square).
Washington was a speculative city from the very start—George Washington [Yeah, me and those muppets. . . ] sought the support of merchant landholders in Alexandria and Georgetown as early as 1790 in an attempt to acquire land for the burgeoning city. These landholders were encouraged to sell their lands to City Commissioners, who would then turn around and sell off the city lands at public auction to interested buyers. The merchant-landholder relevant to our purposes is Samuel Davidson—Stephen Decatur bought most of his land from Davidson’s son, Lewis, during that 1817-1819 timeframe.
Samuel Davidson is what many historians would term your “typical” speculator . . . he invested in land simply to turn a profit, not necessarily to engage in any future development upon that land (this is a huge generalization, but it works right now).
[Side note: Davidson is a craaaaaaaazy dude. Some day I will regale you with two tales. One involves Davidson, a disputed game of Whist, a menacing walking stick, and a duel threat . . . and the other concerns his failing health and a letter which ends with the declaration “I hope his testicles meet the same fate as mine!”]
When Stephen Decatur arrives in Washington, the city is finally starting to establish itself as a permanent urban base. The Federal City had maintained a relatively transient population for its first two decades, owing in large part to the nature of political life since many Congressmen did not reside in Washington year round. There were, however, a few wealthy Washingtonians who did decide to put down permanent roots. In 1798, Col. John Tayloe III and architect William Thornton (architect of the US Capitol) built the Octagon House adjacent to the President’s House on Square 170.
One of the most interesting finds so far is that the first place Stephen Decatur decides to purchase land in Washington is on Square 170, in a lot close to the Octagon House. (I mean, this makes perfect social sense, right? If you’re a “nouveau riche” member of elite society hoping to establish solid footing with the “right” circles, you’re going to align yourself with those persons and environments that will help you do that.) His first land purchase aligned him with the Tayloe Family. But he doesn’t build on these lots. Instead, he moves his attentions to Square 167, on the corner of President’s Park, adjacent to the White House.
Now, it’s important to note that men like Stephen Decatur would not have classified themselves as land speculators. Decatur was a Naval hero, a gentleman, and a person of privilege. To speculate for speculations sake was beneath him and his accomplishments. Thus, Decatur decides to construct a permanent residence for himself and his wife on Square 167 (the present site of the Decatur House) and hires Benjamin Henry Latrobe [SUPER HAWT] to do it. This way Decatur can remove himself from those associations with “typical” speculators and can continue to cultivate his image as a genteel military hero, while still investing heavily in the purchase and sale of city lands. DO WE BUY THIS? I’M NOT SURE YET . . . but it’s what makes the most sense right now.
Where do I go from here?
That’s a great question . . . because, ol’ Stevie D up there had to go get himself killed in a duel in March of 1820 (yeah, they did that a lot back then), so the historical record gets extremely hazy around that time. Latrobe also loses all of his paperwork during his travels and then also dies, so it’s quite difficult to establish a solid sense of what is going on. (Gosh, why do they go and do that? Don’t they know that 200 years later they’re gipping me of crucial info?)
Over the past week I’ve made my way through ALL of the files and binders at the Decatur House attempting to piece together what the heck is going on here (it’s been quite frustrating . . .).
My next step is to look into the roles which women—specifically Susan Decatur—and slaves (there are no records specifically stating that the Decatur’s owned slaves in Washington, but there are hints) played in this story. The culture of genteel entertainment, hospitality, and social life were (and still are!) major factors in the development of elite Washingtonian society at the Decatur House.
And with that, I need to stop thinking about the Decaturs today. Goooood night.